Telluride Real Estate Market Report — October 2026

October 2026 market report · Data: Telluride Consulting (official September, county-wide) and Telluride MLS (October 1-10 recorded activity, Telluride / Mountain Village / Placerville). All figures verified at publication.

Markets talk two ways: through closings, and through what comes to market. September spoke through closings. The first week of October answered with inventory — and it answered loudly.

Three trophies in 72 hours

Between October 5 and October 7, three listings over $15 million hit the Telluride MLS: 8121 Preserve Drive at $28.75M, 453 Benchmark Drive at $26.95M, and 113 Palmyra Drive at $16.995M — that last one is ours, a brand-new 5-bedroom, 6,819-square-foot build on .68 acres in Mountain Village. Call it $72.7 million of trophy inventory in one week.

Why that matters: properties over $5 million have produced 52% of all county dollar volume in 2026 while making up just 12% of transactions. The segment driving this market spent the summer starved for fresh product. It just got restocked — heading into ski season, when trophy buyers actually show up.

September, now official

Telluride Consulting’s county-wide September report is out: $121.9 million across 38 sales. The Town of Telluride printed $59.8 million — up 79% year over year — and together with Mountain Village ($57.7M) accounted for 96% of every dollar that closed in the county. Year to date the county sits at $724.2 million, up 13% on 9% fewer transactions, with the average sale at $2.39 million, up 24%. Telluride’s YTD average price per unit is up 44%.

A note on our own process, because we think it’s worth being graded in public: our early-read September report, published October 1 from MLS-recorded sales, put Telluride and Mountain Village at $112.9 million. The official figure landed at $117.5 million — our early number came within 4%, on the conservative side, with the gap explained by non-MLS transfers and recording timing. We’ll keep publishing early and reconciling openly. In a market where a couple of sales can swing any statistic — they always can here — showing the work is the whole point.

The first prints of October

Closings recorded in the October 1-10 window (including two late-September sales that recorded after our last report):

1268 Brown Ranch Road — $11.03 million, 100.7% of asking. Closed September 30, over list after 229 days on market. A statement result for the Placerville corridor, and a recording-timing note worth flagging: it doesn’t appear in the official September county total, so expect it to bolster October’s.
517 E Columbia Avenue — $7.1 million at $3,158/SF. The Town’s $3,000/SF line — the threshold we flagged in September — has now been cleared in three consecutive months.
785 Smuggler St — $4.0 million, 70 days on market.
Plus a $1.6 million land closing and two down-valley homes — the ladder has rungs at every level.
Under contract: 12 properties carrying $41.5 million in asking price, led by two residences at 150 W Pacific ($10.5M and $8.95M) and 108 Lone Fir in Mountain Village ($5.9M). September’s pipeline is converting, not stalling.

The churn nobody talks about

Here’s the honest counterweight: in the same ten days, eleven listings carrying roughly $36 million in asking price expired or were withdrawn. The market is sorting itself — fresh, correctly priced trophy product arriving at the top while stale listings quietly leave the board. If your property has been sitting, that’s not a reason to despair; it’s a reason to have a real pricing conversation. The September data told us exactly what pricing right was worth: about four points of close ratio and a hundred days of your life.

What this means

For buyers: the most selection the trophy segment has offered all year just arrived, and sellers of long-listed properties averaged 94% of ask last month. Both facts are leverage — if you know which properties they apply to.

For sellers: you now share the stage with $72.7 million of brand-new competition. The listings that cleared last month priced to the market and moved in roughly 100 days. We’ll show you exactly where your property sits before ski season opens the buying window.

Adam Black · THE A-TEAM at Telluride Properties
A Forbes Global Properties affiliate
970-729-0568 · [email protected]
560 Mountain Village Blvd, Suite 103, Mountain Village, CO 81435
TellurideRealEstateSearch.com

Sources: Telluride Consulting (September 2026 Comparative Sales Report, county-wide, tracking all recorded sales including non-MLS) and Telluride MLS (October 1-10, 2026 recorded activity for Telluride, Mountain Village and Placerville addresses). Small-market caveat, stated as always: a handful of sales can swing any segment’s figures; these numbers describe the market, not the value of any individual property. 113 Palmyra Drive is listed by Adam Black and Aric Maloy, THE A-TEAM at Telluride Properties.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the official September numbers show for San Miguel County?

$121.9 million across 38 sales. The Town of Telluride accounted for $59.8 million, up 79% year over year, and Mountain Village $57.7 million; together they made up 96% of county dollars. Year to date, the county is at $724.2 million, up 13% on 9% fewer transactions, with an average sale of $2.39 million, up 24%.

What closed in the first ten days of October?

Recorded closings from October 1–10 included 1268 Brown Ranch Road at $11.03 million (100.7% of asking, closed September 30, over list after 229 days on market), 517 E Columbia Avenue at $7.1 million ($3,158/SF), and 785 Smuggler St at $4.0 million (70 days on market), plus a $1.6 million land closing and two down-valley homes.

What is the churn point in the October report?

In the same ten days, eleven listings carrying roughly $36 million in asking price expired or were withdrawn. The report ties that to pricing: overpricing costs “about four points of close ratio and a hundred days of your life”.

What does the October report mean for buyers?

Sellers of long-listed properties averaged 94% of ask last month, so stale listings carry room — but listings that cleared last month priced to the market and moved in roughly 100 days, and 12 properties carrying $41.5 million in asking price were under contract, so well-priced homes still move.

What does it mean for sellers?

Listings that cleared last month priced to the market and moved in roughly 100 days. In the same ten days, eleven listings carrying roughly $36 million in asking price expired or were withdrawn. In the Town, the $3,000/SF line was cleared in three consecutive months, with 517 E Columbia Avenue closing at $7.1 million ($3,158/SF).

Buying in Telluride or Mountain Village? I answered the 10 questions buyers ask me most.